Thursday, July 31, 2014

D Day

The night the lights go out in Lincoln Center...
Here in Dubuque, Iowa, I am a long ways from New York City.  Surprisingly enough, the closest I've ever been was an unintended fly-through at JFK.  But, as I've written several times, most recently here, events in the Big Apple, have ramifications that resound across the spectrum of issues artistic, economic, political and much, much more.

July 31 marks the end of the current contracts (across the board) between the Metropolitan Opera and its myriad employees, from musicians, to costumers, set designers, make-up, and so many more.  In the Adaptistration blog, Drew McManus' headline is "Today is the Last Day of the Met as You Know It."  There are serious consequences for an employer initiated lockout beyond the short term:

"The New York Times published an article on 7/29/2014 by Michael Cooper that takes a step back to add some perspective to the rhetoric and recounts how difficult it was for the Met’s ticket sales to bounce back from their last work stoppage in 1980. When taking into consideration the Met’s current earned income shortfalls, a work stoppage without at least some effort to play and talk carries greater potential to exacerbate what the Met has defined as a crucial problem."

Simply remembering the impact that work stoppages in major sports (I'm thinking baseball and hockey in particular) had on future ticket sales--it took years for fans to start returning to the ballparks--does not bode well for the Met, which is already in a precarious position, because, as Greg Sandow notes (in his third installment of the "Peter Gelb Furor"):

"Peter Gelb has one further problem. His productions haven’t been good. So at a time when costs are rising, and opera ticket sales are falling all over the US, they’re falling even more at the Met, because some not negligibly small number of people don’t want to see what Peter’s putting on the stage,

So no wonder Peter urgently feels he has to do something. Of course that means more than confronting the unions. The Met has to become hot again, as it briefly was when Peter first came there. It has to be buzzing with excitement that even people who don’t normally go to the opera pick up on.

But even then — and even if the productions were terrific — the confrontation would have to happen, as it’s happened elsewhere, because the cost structure isn’t sustainable. It would just be easier — much easier — if the productions were good.

To reuse some words from my last post: Wouldn’t Peter’s negotiating position be much stronger if his new productions had been triumphs, and a whole new audience — as was his original plan — came flocking to see them?"


So the Met is locked into a position with rising labor costs due to new productions, and simply cost-of-living increases.  And the public is rejecting the new productions.  Even the highly touted HD broadcasts are not generating the intended income, although I think that this was a tremendous idea to bring the Met stage to those of us far from NYC who cannot afford the trip and the high costs of tickets.  The added bonus is, of course, that I can sit in an extremely comfortable seat with a tub of popcorn, one of my favorite pastimes.  

Federal mediators have been called in, but time is beyond short.  Management hasn't proposed a "talk and play" position, something which has worked well in a variety of other cultural organizations.  Even the Philadelphia Orchestra didn't stop playing as it traversed its journey through Chapter 11.

Will a lockout at the Met directly impact those of us in the Heartland?  Eventually, yes, as we won't be able to tune into radio broadcasts in the fall (of course, those can be supplanted by other companies).  It is unfortunate that this vaunted institution thinks of itself as too big to fail.  One can only hope for a miracle.








Wednesday, July 30, 2014

Score one for US!

2013 NYO-USA at the Proms in London

The National Youth Orchestra of the United States of America debuted in summer 2013.  Consisting of young (ages 16-19) the ensemble is organized by Carnegie Hall's Weill Institute and spends a two-week residency at Purchase College, New York.  Following that the orchestra embarks on a national or international tour.

The first incarnation of the orchestra was led by the ubiquitous Valery Gergiev, him of hundreds of performances every year.  Surely this was just another feather in a cap that resembles the plumage of a peacock.  Not surprising, the inaugural program included Tchaikovsky (Violin Concerto) and the Tenth Symphony of Dmitri Shostakovich.  The tour brought the ensemble to concerts in Russia, the UK and Washington, D.C.

David Robertson
THIS YEAR, the orchestra engaged an AMERICAN(!) as conductor:  David Robertson of the St. Louis Symphony.  Ever since I first saw him conduct in Chicago, I thought that he was on a trajectory for greater things.  Possibly he has been swept aside for the current youth movement in New York (Alan Gilbert, 47), Boston (Andris Nelsons, 35), and Philadelphia (Yannick Nézet-Séguin, 39).  Robertson himself is a ripe old 56!  Still, it is beyond wonderful that Robertson represents the USA in an orchestra made up of young citizens of the USA.  The last thing I want to sound is provincial, but there are so many fine American conductors that we shouldn't have to look elsewhere.

Robertson's repertoire better reflects our nation's heritage as well.  It includes a modern classic, the Symphonic Dances from Bernstein's West Side Story, and a new work, Samuel Carl Adams Radical Play, a special commission from Carnegie Hall, the orchestra's principal sponsor.  The remaining repertoire of the tour--which will visit seven U.S. cities and include performances at both Carnegie and L.A.'s Disney Hall--consists of Britten's Violin Concerto (with Gil Shaham) and Mussorgsky's Pictures.

Andrew Patner of the Chicago Sun-Times wrote of the orchestra's July 28 performance at Grant Park:

NYO-USA in Grant Park, Chicago
What the NYO has, in addition to geographic diversity and rather cool bright red pants with complementing red-striped white sneakers, is exposure, marquee leadership, memorable tutors and a big travel budget. And these are important to all lovers of classical music as a living art form. There were many peers of the players in the audience at the Pritzker Pavilion in Millennium Park. And many newcomers to any orchestral program. These young artists will never forget these experiences. (This year’s roster includes 24 musicians from last season.) They got to Carnegie Hall. They’ll be ambassadors for playing, listening to and supporting great music all of their lives.

We must take pride in these fantastic musicians as they boldly represent that which is best about America and American music.

That's the upside.  Next year's conductor?  Charles Dutoit.  Yep, he's Swiss....

Thursday, July 24, 2014

A Lockout Looms


Today's New York Times reports that the administration of the Metropolitan Opera is poised for a lockout of its employees beginning August 1.  Gelb and company have decided to definitely take the lowest road in this ongoing labor battle.

Vänskä: needing to rebuild.
Events of the past couple of years have demonstrated that lockouts of musicians and other employees simply does not work.  It didn't work in Atlanta; it definitely didn't work in Minneapolis, where CEO Michael Henson is out the door and Music Director Osmo Vänskä is back in.  Of course, the long-term implications of these actions are still in play.  Exactly how long will it take to bring the orchestra (s) back to form.

The DSO at Carnegie Hall
While the post-strike Detroit Symphony received accolades for its Spring 2013 appearance at Carnegie Hall, the jury must still be out considering that the players have had to endure an average 22% cut in salary.  Nevertheless, in discussing the final weekend of that year's Spring for Music festival, reviewer James Oestreich opined,

As expected, the high point came on Friday evening with Detroit’s audacious presentation of an “Ives Immersion”: all four of Charles Ives’s numbered symphonies in chronological order. Obvious in retrospect (though not likely to be repeated often, given its strenuous demands on performers and listeners alike), the program made for an extraordinary journey, from the relatively conventional sensibility of a prodigious student composer in the First Symphony to the unfettered one of an indomitable master in the Fourth.

One has to wonder if this is the only choice for the Met.  Could management and unions agree on a temporary extension of current agreements while negotiations (if one can call them that) continue?  It would avoid (temporarily, at least) the disastrous contract talks of 1969 and 1980.  The former resulted in the need for years of recovery of the Met's subscriber base.  As the house is already suffering from lowered subscribers and single ticket sales, one has to wonder how much of a financial hit the Met can endure.

One thing is certain. Allan Gordon, the executive director of the American Guild of Musical Artists, which represents the chorus and others at the opera house, has determined that there is exactly zero chance of resolving current conflicts before the July 31 deadline. And THAT will probably leave Mr. Gelb in the same boat as Minnesota's Hensen, who continued to receive his salary, heading an organization which gave not a single performance.

“He has no intention of actually reaching an agreement by Aug. 1 unless it’s his agreement,” Mr. Gordon said of Mr. Gelb. He also said: “Once he locks out employees, his relationship with the performers at the Met is over. They will never respect him again. He’ll be the captain of a ship where the crew is just waiting for a chance to mutiny.”

As I have written before, the Met has a number of systemic problems that are not going to be solved overnight.  Its 3800-seat auditorium will probably not sell out night after night even in the best of economical times.  The organization is simply collapsing under its only weight.  And speaking of weight, I do believe that the fat lady is warming up.


Wednesday, July 23, 2014

Seven words that irk me like few others...


"But we've never done it that way."  Or variations on the theme:  "It's worked ok for ___ (insert number of years); why change it now?"  I am trying to imagine how the scions of industry would have reacted to these kinds of questions.
  • Lee Iacocca, credited with engineering Ford's Mustang and (more infamously) the Pinto, was released from his position and snapped up by Chrysler.  He turned that company around, through introducing new models, assuring federal loan guarantees to help through a 1979 fiscal crisis, and so much more.  He definitely changed the way things had been done.
  • Steve Jobs, founder of Apple and the leader in the personal computer revolution.  Sacked by the company in 1985, he soon acquired Pixar, which had spun off from Lucasfilms.  The rest is history; he returned to Apple in 1998 and led the development of iMac, iTunes, iPod, iPhone, and iPad, and on the services side, the company's Apple Retail Stores, iTunes Store and the App Store. There may be no corporate turnaround as dramatic as that engineered by Jobs, who definitely thought "out of the box."
  • In the political spectrum, one recalls Presidents who were great thinkers:  Thomas Jefferson must head the list.  Abraham Lincoln, trying to preserve the stability of our nation, instead was forced to lead us through a ferocious civil war.  Others who ably served in times of trial must include Woodrow Wilson and, of course, FDR.  In the latter's case, the New Deal policies enacted were actually variations on tropes put in place by Republicans (the great mayors of Detroit come to mind) several decades before.  If only we still enjoyed leaders who managed to put partisan rhetoric aside and worked for the good of all.


Michael Reardon writes how this thinking effects the non-profit sector.  Kathleen Fitzpatrick comments on its affect on the Scholarly Journal.

There are, of course, many others who chose to buck prevailing trends in their businesses, political arenas, or even the arts and cultural sectors.  Whenever there is a major change in the leadership of a cultural organization, the result is either amazingly positive (the LA Philharmonic) or potentially disastrous (the impending strike/lockout at the MET--eight days and counting).  

This even occurs on a much smaller level.  I cannot count the number of times I've heard, "We never did it that way before," from my earliest years of teaching to the present.  Of course, one often learns the hard way, and I've taught myself to take my time, analyze the situation/organization and then propose what I see as incremental steps toward leading an organization/ensemble towed its greater mission.  Sounds easy....if only....

One of my current ensembles was faced with a crisis of monumental proportions in the Winter of 2008.  We suddenly found ourselves without a rehearsal space, necessary equipment, and a music library.  A rejuvenated Board of Directors worked hard to rectify all of those problems in a very short time.  But, since that time, the organization has been coasting and it's time to pick things up a notch and, in particular, expand our outreach.  I think they're ready.

Two other ensembles have similar problems in terms of rehearsal and performance venues, both of which are woefully inadequate and, in many ways, detrimental to fine music making.  One has been slowly improving (often in baby steps, but still moving forward).  The other wants very strongly to be better than it is.  It's a matter of substantive change for one and a change of mindset for another.  What will it take?  I'm not sure, but again, changes in leadership can lead organizations out of the doldrums or simply an organizational rut.  Like businesses, cultural entities must always be moving in a positive direction.  We need to constantly improve music making and marketing of that product.  There's really no time for resting on laurels, real or imagined.  

So, when I hear those seven little words, I'm tempted to respond in ways that I probably shouldn't.  Fortunately, I've basically learned from the errors of my youth and have tried to surround myself with like thinkers.  There are more than one might imagine.


Sunday, July 20, 2014

The cream always rises to the top

The Tri-State Wind Symphony, June 26, 2014
In every year since our second season (I believe), the players of the Tri-State Wind Symphony have selected the season's final concert program, the Player's Favorites.  Of course, they are selecting from those works that the conductor has already programmed for the individual concerts, so there is an initial kind of "expectation" of the repertoire that they have from which to choose.  BUT, over the years, I have continually been pleasantly surprised when the "cream rises to the top," i.e. the members always seem to select the best works among their favorites.  For example, this year the top five votes went to:

  • Karl L. King:  Thumbs Up USA
  • Karl L. King:  Emblem of Freedom
  • Steven Reineke:  Sedona
  • Meredith Willson:  The Unsinkable Molly Brown
  • Gaetano Donizetti/Alford:  Lucy's Sextette (A Ragtime Travesty)

Karl King--Number 1 & 2!
It's surprising that two marches by the same composer rose to the top, although I'll admit that I've programmed more King this summer than ever before.  I suppose its due to my experience with Barnum and Bailey's Favorite, prepared by the QCWE for our first concert and used as an encore on two subsequent performances.  We worked out the nuance of this incredible piece so that I thought we put a stamp on this march that said, "This is high art."  Another interesting note is that none of these pieces has been in our repertoire prior to this year.  I know that if I'd planned on a Holst Suite, that would have been number one (it always is) and it's probably time to pull out the F-Suite (No. 2) as we've not played it in a few.

The same holds true with the Bettendorf Park Band, which I assumed directorship this spring.  The final concert that we will present includes the following:
  • George Gershwin/Moss:  Strike Up the Band
  • James Swearingen:  Flight of Valor
  • John WilliamsLavender:  Hymn to the Fallen
  • Gustav Holst:  Suite in E-flat (the clear favorite!)
  • Johann Strauss/Carey:  Thunder and Lightning Polka
  • John Barry/Bocook:  Dances With Wolves
  • arr. Barker:  Magic of Andrew Lloyd Webber
  • John Philip Sousa:  Washington Post
Gustav Holst, the cream always rises!
A few surprises as we spent a good part of our most recent rehearsal "righting the wrongs" in Flight of Valor, a particularly evocative piece from a composer I've never been particularly enamored with, but this one is special.  Hymn to the Fallen was a challenge for the band and I was glad to see it selected.  And the Lloyd Webber medley?  We whipped that one up in one rehearsal and the ensemble did a wonderful job!

But poor Karl King.  We played Thumbs Up with the BPB as well, along with Alhambra Grotto and Invictus (another circus masterpiece).  I just think that the band has tired of a lot of King over the years and I probably need to retire him for a season or two.  There's still plenty of good stuff out there!

Now the real challenge will be in conducting one ensemble on July 31 and the next on August 1.  As long as I'm in the right city, I guess I'll be ok.

Oops!  Wrong band!  Leading the DCamp "Family Band" from a saxophone part!

Here's the right band:  the BPB on July 4...


Friday, July 18, 2014

Spurious correlations....

For once this week I'm not going to mention Peter Gelb and the travails of the MET--Oops, I did it again.  Ok, let's get it out of the way:  read here for a discussion of the problem and why things are probably going to get MUCH worse.  Read here for a completely different take on the art, a whole new concept, completely opposite of the behemoth in Lincoln Center.  And, for one of the few times in recorded history, I find myself in disagreement with Greg Sandow.  Here is why.

BUT--ENOUGH ALREADY!!!  What about these spurious correlations?  Being one day past the 25th anniversary of Karajan's death, I'm naturally thinking about the great stick beaters of the past.  This ruminating led me to wonder,

WHAT IF:

Furtwangler in Chicago?
Gustav Heinrich Ernst Martin Wilhelm Furtwängler (yep, that was his given name; a bit of overkill if you ask me) had been able to accept the offer as Music Director of the Chicago Symphony in 1949?  The offer was eventually rescinded due to protestations from the likes of Arturo Toscanini, George Szell, Vladimir Horowitz, Arthur Rubinstein, and Isaac Stern, all of whom threatened to boycott an ensemble that would hire a Nazi sympathizer (he wasn't).  In fact, Yehudi Menuhin stated in a lengthy letter to the tribunal that Furtwängler faced following the War:

Unless you have secret incriminating evidence against Furtwängler supporting your accusation that he was a tool of Nazi Party, I beg to take violent issue with your decision to ban him. The man never was a Party member. Upon numerous occasions, he risked his own safety and reputation to protect friends and colleagues. Do not believe that the fact of remaining in one's own country is alone sufficient to condemn a man. On the contrary, as a military man, you would know that remaining at one's post often requires greater courage than running away. He saved, and for that we are deeply his debtors, the best part of his own German culture.

So, instead of Furtwängler, the orchestra endured the unremarkable tenures of Désiré Defauw and Artur Rodziński.  But then KUBELIK ARRIVED!

WHAT IF:

What if Kubelik had stayed?
Stupid critics!
Dumb Boards!
Kubelik had lasted more than three years in Chicago?  The semi-official line is that he was "hounded out of the city" (according to Time) after repeated attacks by critic Claudia Cassidy.  Chicago Sun-Times music critic Robert C. Marsh argued in 1972 that it was the Chicago Symphony trustees who were behind the departure. Their foremost complaint, and that of Cassidy as well, was that Kubelík introduced too many contemporary works (about 70) to the orchestra; there were also objections to his demanding exhaustive rehearsals and engaging several black artists.  Oh my!  Integrating the lily white halls of classical music!  I heard a 1951 Pictures under Kubelik, recorded in the very early careers of Herseth, Farkas and Jacobs, among others.  Astonishing....

So let's see Furtwängler, possibly followed (a bit later) by Kubelik.  Too good to be true.  No to the irascible Fritz Reiner?  How many other things might have been different?

WHAT IF:

The Philadelphia Orchestra, after the retirement (after 44 years) of Eugene Ormandy in 1980, had hired anyone other than Riccardo Muti?  Remember, too, that Ormandy's 44 years came right after Stokowski's nearly 30.  At that time there still existed orchestras with their own distinctive sounds; the Philly had been cultivated by Stokowski and Ormandy to play with a lush string tone achieved in the former's sense through cross bowings.  These were also Music Directors who signed with an orchestra and basically stayed with the orchestra for the entire season, as opposed to the jet-setting maestri of today who give oftentimes as little as 8-10 weeks to their "real" gig.  That's discussion for another time.

A younger Sawallisch instead?
Muti, then a young lad of 39, turned the Philadelphia Orchestra into just another generic band; apparently, recording engineers loved it. For me, every Philadelphia /Muti recording I own is dull in sound, scope, and sheen (or the lack thereof). And who followed him? Wolfgang Sawallisch (1993-2003), Christoph Eschenbach (2003-07, or thereabouts), and Charles Dutoit (2008-2012). This was truly a difficult period in the history of this great orchestra. Eschenbach, never a fan or player favorite (and one who has continued to receive negative press for his opera performances), he was scorned in the local press. Peter Dobrin wrote in the Philadelphia Inquirer, "In three seasons, Eschenbach and the orchestra have produced a handful of brilliant concerts.  More often, though, his rehearsals and performances have elicited a long list of complaints from musicians: getting lost in the score at concerts; leading disorganized rehearsals and then asking for overtime; and insisting on a peculiar rushing and slowing of tempos."

How much of these obvious wrong moves contributed to the orchestra's infamous 2011 bankruptcy?  Probably little, but one does have to consider public perception of the end product.

OR, (and this was the impetus for this diatribe) WHAT IF

Kertesz instead of Maazel
Upon the death of long-time Music Director George Szell in 1972, the Cleveland Orchestra had not hired Lorin Maazel?  The players themselves voted 96-2 to urge the Musical Arts Society to hire Istvan Kertesz.  I am trying to imagine the refined and precise "European" orchestra that Szell created in the hands of that young firebrand.  The results could have been electrifying.  Maazel himself, who would eventually experience success around the world, admitted in 2002 that “the relationship (in Cleveland) remained more or less rocky to the end.”

BUT, the most spurious correlation is this:  Kertesz did not conduct in Cleveland and the following April he drowned off the coast of Israel.  If only, he'd been leading a concert in Severance Hall instead.... 




Tuesday, July 15, 2014

Conflicted....

Lorin Maazel (1930-2014)
As conflicted as I am about the happenings at the Metropolitan Opera (I really don't think that stage hands should earn $400K/year) or the state of our art in general, a big recent happening has me more so.  No sooner had I read Norman Lebrecht's column regarding the improvement in the health of conductor Lorin Maazel and his continuing work at his summer festival at Castleton, VA, was his death announced throughout worldwide media.  The maestro had been absent from concert stages for many months, having been recovering from surgery.  The cause of death has been listed as "complications from pneumonia."  Regardless of the cause, Mr. Maazel, who died at 84, had lived a long and highly productive life.

He was a performing and conducting wunderkind, having led a broadcast concert when he was eight years old (that's right-8!).  He was the first American (and Jewish no less) to lead a performance at the Festspielhaus in Bayreuth.  He would go on to lead three major American orchestras: Cleveland (replacing George Szell, 1972-82), Pittsburgh (1986-96), and New York (2002-09).  He also served a short stint as Music Director of the Vienna State Opera, and also with the Bavarian Radio Symphony and Munich Philharmonic.

Maazel was renowned for his amazing memory, capable of leading Lulu without a score and, particularly his remarkable efficiency in rehearsal.  But his performances never seemed to add up to a body of work to place him in the pantheon of first-rate conductors.  Mr. Lebrecht wrote in today's Slipped Disc blog:

Lorin belonged everywhere and nowhere. He was never embraced as an American marvel, as Bernstein and Previn were, nor was he ever allowed to feel wholly at home in Berlin, Vienna or Munich, his three European bases. In Vienna, he faced an onslaught of xenophobia that was part anti-American, part anti-semitic. Lorin never acknowledged these currents (to me), but his isolation was, in 1984 Vienna, absolute.  Munich may have been a little warmer, Berlin a little worse.  After being voted down by the players as Karajan’s successor, he swore he would never conduct the (Berlin) Philharmonic again. He relented, once. It went badly and he vanished again.

My own personal experience with Maazel came but once, as the mighty Clevelanders visited East Lansing, Michigan (and that horrible 3600-seat monstrosity) while on tour in early May, 1976.  A student friend had called me and said she could get discounted student tickets but wanted to know if the orchestra was any good....I had to laugh.  We managed tenth row, center.  Fabulous seats even in that behemoth.

The Philadelphia Orchestra at Hill Auditorium
University of Michigan, May 1974
For many years I'd forgotten the program and one day it suddenly came back to me.  Only two works were performed, Prokofiev's Classical Symphony and the Seventh of Dvorak (I'm quite sure).  Of course, the orchestra played well; the many years under Szell had turned it into an almost unparalleled virtuoso machine.  And that's what it seemed to be to me--a machine.  I left the concert feeling more than a bit cold and under the impression that I'd witnessed a concert that was just going through the motions.  Of course my memory has to be tempered by the fact that I heard the Philly Orchestra in the same hall at the end of that month, a concert that closed with Mahler's First, my introduction to that composer.  A fair comparison?  Probably not, but those are the facts.

Through his tenure in New York, Maazel was viewed as a conductor capable of brilliance and outright mediocrity.  Perhaps his great mind just sometimes got in the way.  Needless to say, I have to (unfortunately) admit that I'd caught him on a bad day.